Day 374: More than a year, and no closer to being paid off

I have read a lot of doom and gloom articles online lately. How can you not, though, given the current economic situation. But more important than the articles themselves are the comments that follow them. They truly paint a picture of the American psychie, or do they?

Last week, I read an article about how the personal savings rate should be 16-20%. Although it did not state whether that was 16-20% of gross or net pay, I don't think it was really relavent. My initial thought was "How on earth is anybody supposed to save 16-20% of their pay??" And then, I looked at my own personal finances. I currently throw $200 a paycheck into my savings account, and another $25 per pay into each of my children's savings accounts. There is very little return on investment right now, but I am not confident enough in our economy to save money any other way. After combining mine and my husband's salaries, I discovered that I am currently saving about 15% of my gross income and about 9% of our combined gross income. That doesn't sound like much, in comparison to the recommended 16% savings rate but, there are weeks that we have extra money after paying bills. I leave $100 in our checking account to spend for the week and throw the rest into a savings account. I do this on two different bank accounts. By the end of the year, I will have saved approximately 11% of our gross income, based on current projections and IF we face no emergencies that require withdrawal from those accounts.

Based on last years tax return and my current withholdings, I estimate we will receive a $2000-$2500 tax return this year. It is considerably less than the $4000 we received last year, but that's because the other half of that money is already being put into savings. This is the first year I have claimed more than zero exemptions, but I kept reading about how I should get that money now and not let the federal government have it for free, so I did what was suggested. Next year, I'll bump it up and hopefully break even.

Once we pay off some of our credit cards, loans, etc, we will have eliminated about $500 in expenditures, half of which can go into savings as well.

In taking steps to consolidate our debt, I applied for a consolidation loan. I didn't originally plan to, I just contacted my credit union to find out the terms of the consolidation loan, but when they gave me a call to discuss the terms of the loan, they pulled up my account and filled out the application. I was approved immediately, and within two hours, had the money deposited into my account for me to distribute as needed. I paid off one credit card, a loan, and the majority of a second credit card. That second credit card will be paid off this month as well.

I went back and forth on the consolidation loan, because there is an early pre-payment fee that if it is paid off in less than 2.5 years, I am charged a $50 fee. I did a quick look at how much I was paying in interest on these cards and loans, and determined that it was well worth it, even with a $50 prepayment fee. We will likely pay a chunk of the loan off with my bonus next year, and continue to make monthly payments before and after that time. If I ever get the raise that I am expecting (hoping for), it will help significantly.

I also decided on the consolidation loan because I have learned that if we have a zero balance on a credit card, we are a lot less likely to use it. Something about putting a balance on a card that was previously paid off just bothers me psychologically, but if there is a balance, I know I'm making a payment on that card anyway, so I am more inclined to use it for random spending. At least with the consolidation loan, I will not be able to amass any more debt on it. There is a fixed amount that I will be paying on for a predetermined amount of time and once it's paid off, it's paid off.

Another fun thing that I learned, that has bolstered my confidence a little, is that we have finally reached a point financially where we're not spending more than we're making. I know it seems a little backwards to be putting money into savings when we were using credit cards to meet basic financial needs, but I felt like (and still do) that if either of us were to lose our jobs, I would rather have money in the bank than a paid off credit card. I can negotiate with a lender, but if I have a $0 balance credit card and no income, it won't be long before access to my card is shut off. So I have been using my lowest interest credit card to pay for basic necessities, like gas and groceries, and then making the same $250 payment every month.

That said, here is a picture of my current debt totals for June.

Day 354: May Totals and Random Updates

I believe when we last left off, I had recently had an interview and was waiting for word as to whether I would get a promotion to a new position, or whether my job audit would net me a promotion in my current role.

I'm sad to say that neither happened. The job I had interviewed for decided that I did not have enough experience, which I guess I can see since everybody else they interviewed was a business analyst and I am just in sales support. It doesn't make it any less disappointing though. HR responded to my job audit by stating that, although I'm doing more work than required for my position, the extra work that I'm doing is not required for my current position and is simply an added benefit that I bring to the job, so they told my manager that my job could not be reclassified.

So I got no more money. However, after three years, my husband finally got a $0.75 an hour raise. I personally feel it should have been more, given that they haven't given raises in three years, but I'm glad he got something. His company has now started offering a retirement plan too, so we will be filling out the paperwork to start contributions to that as well. It will be a hit to our take home pay, but I'll be glad that he's saving something for retirement. I will likely start contributing again after the first of the year, possibly with my merit raise next year.

While it's disappointing that my current department gave me nothing for my efforts, my manager did say that she could give me a merit raise at my midyear review, and another one next spring. I'm anxious to see what kind of increase I get at midyear.

My student loan payment is going to go up $10 a month after my August payment, as part of my graduated repayment plan.

I have noticed that several readers have ended up on my blog for searching the term "What is a grandfathered repayment plan." From what I understand, there was a revision in the student loan terms, both pertaining to interest rates and payment terms for student loans. I believe this was in 2006, but don't hold me to it. At the time, it seemed like a great idea, because it made all student loans fixed rate, instead of variable, and was locked in at the "low" interest rate of 6.some-odd percent. As we all know, when the economy tanked, this "low rate" was no longer a low rate, but I guess that's how things work. From comparing my payments on my current (grandfathered) repayment plan and the new repayment plans, it appears that the new plans have smaller incremental increases on the graduated plan, but the loan is stretched out for a longer period of time. I believe when I signed my loan paperwork, the longest a loan could be repaid on was 20 years. Now it is 25. Similarly, extended repayment plans can last for 25 years, instead of 20.

I think this is kind of a catch 22 for consumers. When I began repayment on my loans about five years ago, I only had 20 years to pay them off. Yes, my payments are going to increase every two years so I will be paying larger payments towards the end of my repayment period, but I only have 15 more years of paying on them. I have been considering consolidating my loans that were not included in the initial consolidation so all of my loans will be locked in at the same rate, however I believe that this resets my payments to another 25 years (unless I make additional payments on the principal) and I end up paying more interest in the long run. Do I consolidate an lock in the 2.something interest rates on my currently variable loans, or do I leave the two separate and pay them off in 15 years?

If I were making any headway on our debt payment plan, I would leave them as is. My student loans would be paid off in less than 10 years, and if my interest rate on the variable loan skyrocketed, it is legitimately small enough that I could pay it off with a tax return or bonus. But I also know that we always have those returns and bonus's spent before they're even deposited. I hate making grown up decisions.

I actually think I'm becoming a little too obsessive about money, bills, debt and the like. I already have a whole payment plan mapped out for our bills for 2012, and we're not even half way through 2011 yet. I mapped out all of the bills we have to pay, based payments on our current salaries (assuming no increase in salary), assuming no decrease in our mortgage (which we should see because of our decreased homeowners insurance premium), and assuming we continue paying the same monthly payments on credit cards, even as the balances and minimum payments decrease.

And you know what? We have a lot of extra money left after paying bills. Now, it doesn't take into account groceries or gas or any other necessities, but I know approximately how much we spend on these items in a given week or month, and they can fluctuate based on what disposable income we have left after paying bills, but I have to say that unless something catastrophic happens (*knock on wood*), 2012 should be a great year for us financially.

We have 22 weeks where we will have more than $150 after paying bills, 7 of which we will have more than $200, 4 of which we'll have more than $300, and 2 of which we'll have more than $400.

I hope that it actually comes to fruition. That is a lot of extra money to pay towards credit cards. On my spreadsheet, I assumed $200 in spending money (for gas, groceries, and miscellaneous spending) and for weeks with more than $200, I will put everything over $200 in our savings account.

Like I said, I'm a little obsessed about it, and a little crazy for devoting so much time for it, but I think seeing it in black and white helps keep me on track for paying things off in a timely fashion. If I can see where the progress is being made, I'm more likely to stick with it.

Ok, so that's enough rambling I guess. Now I will leave you with pictures of our May debt. This does NOT take into account the money we spent on vacation, as it was not accumulated until June.

As you can see, there wasn't much change in the overall composition of the debt, or the amount of debt paid off.